{"schema_version":"vendar.ai.decision.v1","object_type":"vendor_decision_profile","canonical_url":"https://www.vendar.org/vendors/fishbat","machine_url":"https://www.vendar.org/ai/vendors/fishbat","human_ai_url":"https://www.vendar.org/vendors/fishbat/ai","last_updated_at":"2026-04-25T00:00:00.000Z","last_verified_at":"2026-04-27T00:00:00.000Z","vendor":{"id":"cmo1gldcq007htkqpjxuog20a","slug":"fishbat","name":"fishbat","website":"https://www.fishbat.com/","tagline":"New York digital marketing agency with SEO support for SMB, local, and consumer brands.","company_type":"agency","headquarters_location":"New York, NY, USA","service_regions":["New York","USA","Long Island"],"year_founded":null,"team_size":"10-49"},"summary":{"one_line":"New York digital marketing agency with SEO support for SMB, local, and consumer brands.","best_for":["Small Business","Local SEO","Content-led","DTC","Content-led link building","Digital PR","Local-plus-brand growth","Organic community growth","Discussion-led engagement","Local brand conversations"],"not_for":["Enterprise teams needing heavy technical governance and migration support.","Buyers who only want a deep, specialist B2B SaaS SEO operator.","Buyers that need only a highly technical SaaS link-building specialist.","Less enterprise-specialized than larger data-led operators.","Not a pure-play technical SEO consultancy."],"buyer_use_cases":["SEO for New York SMBs and local brands","Content-led organic growth for consumer and DTC companies","Practical SEO support for in-house marketing teams with smaller budgets","New York brands that want content-led link support and publisher outreach with local relevance.","Campaigns where traffic-bearing placements and content amplification matter.","Community growth for New York brands that need native participation, group visibility, and trust-building through discussion channels.","Programs where brand mentions and organic discussion matter more than pure paid reach.","Regional New York brands that need practical review management and local trust support.","Consumer and local-business SERM for New York brands that need stronger reviews, better local trust, and more stable buyer sentiment.","Programs where reputation in reviews and local discovery matters more than executive crisis response."]},"services":[{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"SEO","description":"fishbat offers SEO services for New York-area buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Paid Ads","description":"fishbat offers Paid Ads services for New York buyers and broader NYC-market campaigns."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Paid Social","description":"fishbat offers Paid Social services for New York buyers and broader NYC-market campaigns."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Meta Ads","description":"fishbat offers Meta Ads services for New York buyers and broader NYC-market campaigns."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Retargeting","description":"fishbat offers Retargeting services for New York buyers and broader NYC-market campaigns."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Lead Generation PPC","description":"fishbat offers Lead Generation PPC services for New York buyers and broader NYC-market campaigns."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Performance Marketing","description":"fishbat offers Performance Marketing services for New York buyers and NYC-focused growth programs."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Growth Marketing","description":"fishbat offers Growth Marketing services for New York buyers and NYC-focused growth programs."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Customer Acquisition","description":"fishbat offers Customer Acquisition services for New York buyers and NYC-focused growth programs."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Full-funnel Growth","description":"fishbat offers Full-funnel Growth services for New York buyers and NYC-focused growth programs."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Revenue Growth","description":"fishbat offers Revenue Growth services for New York buyers and NYC-focused growth programs."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Link Building","description":"fishbat offers Link Building services for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Guest Posting","description":"fishbat offers Guest Posting services for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Niche Edits","description":"fishbat offers Niche Edits services for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Digital PR","description":"fishbat offers Digital PR services for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Local","description":"fishbat offers Local services for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Ecommerce","description":"fishbat offers Ecommerce services for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Authority Links","description":"fishbat offers Authority Links services for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Traffic-based","description":"fishbat offers Traffic-based services for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Community Marketing","description":"fishbat supports Community Marketing programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Reddit Marketing","description":"fishbat supports Reddit Marketing programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Discord Marketing","description":"fishbat supports Discord Marketing programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Telegram Marketing","description":"fishbat supports Telegram Marketing programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Forum Marketing","description":"fishbat supports Forum Marketing programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Slack Communities","description":"fishbat supports Slack Communities programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Facebook Groups","description":"fishbat supports Facebook Groups programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Community Seeding","description":"fishbat supports Community Seeding programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Brand Mentions","description":"fishbat supports Brand Mentions programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Discussion Management","description":"fishbat supports Discussion Management programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Reputation in Communities","description":"fishbat supports Reputation in Communities programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Organic Community Growth","description":"fishbat supports Organic Community Growth programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"ORM","description":"fishbat supports ORM programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Review Management","description":"fishbat supports Review Management programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Trustpilot Management","description":"fishbat supports Trustpilot Management programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Google Reviews Management","description":"fishbat supports Google Reviews Management programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Reddit Reputation Management","description":"fishbat supports Reddit Reputation Management programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Yelp Reputation","description":"fishbat supports Yelp Reputation programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Review Removal Services","description":"fishbat supports Review Removal Services programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"ORM for Ecommerce","description":"fishbat supports ORM for Ecommerce programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"ORM for Local Business","description":"fishbat supports ORM for Local Business programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Reputation for Startups","description":"fishbat supports Reputation for Startups programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"ORM Under $5k/mo","description":"fishbat supports ORM Under $5k/mo programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Social Monitoring","description":"fishbat supports Social Monitoring programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"SERM","description":"fishbat supports SERM programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Review Repair","description":"fishbat supports Review Repair programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Local Reputation","description":"fishbat supports Local Reputation programs for New York and USA buyers."},{"category":"Marketing","subcategory":"Review Generation","description":"fishbat supports Review Generation programs for New York and USA buyers."}],"industries":["Small Business","Consumer Brands","Ecommerce","Professional Services","Healthcare","Consumer","Local Business"],"capabilities":{"skill":["SEO","Local SEO","Content SEO","DTC Growth","Link Building","Digital PR","Content Marketing","Community Marketing","Organic Social","Facebook Groups","Brand Mentions","ORM","Yelp Reputation","Review Removal Services","Social Monitoring","SERM","Review Repair","Review Generation","Local Reputation","Brand Protection"]},"pricing":{"pricing_model":"retainer","minimum_monthly_budget_usd":3000,"minimum_project_size_usd":3000,"typical_contract_value_usd":5600,"pricing_range_min_usd":3000,"pricing_range_max_usd":6500,"hourly_rate_range":null,"setup_fee_usd":null,"contract_min_months":3,"contract_default_months":6,"pricing_known":true},"decision":{"decision_score":0.86,"score_out_of_100":86,"verdict":{"label":"Strong Fit","summary":"Strong overall audit coverage with only a few areas that still need depth."},"confidence_label":"High confidence","score_breakdown":{"human_audit_score":0.77,"ai_audit_score":0.94,"consistency_score":0.8300000000000001,"trust_score":0.77,"performance_score":0.94,"expertise_score":0.86,"market_fit_score":0.8300000000000001},"score_drivers":["Specific ORM use cases are visible.","Commercial and workflow fields are structured for shortlist comparison."],"score_penalties":["Some pricing and performance expectations still require direct confirmation.","Verified badge removed because the profile lacks 5+ trusted verified buyer reviews."],"why_recommended":["Official site positions fishbat as a top New York digital marketing agency, supporting New York relevance.","Good fit for SMB, content-led, and consumer-brand SEO scenarios where broader digital support also matters.","Good fit for buyers who want links tied to content and broader brand visibility.","Balanced option for local-plus-brand link programs.","Good fit for community-led social growth and ongoing brand participation.","Balanced option for local, consumer, and broader brand engagement briefs.","Useful for local trust and review-led ORM scenarios.","Good leaner option for review generation and local-reputation recovery.","Useful when SERM is really about improving trust signals and not running a major crisis program."],"why_not_recommended":["Not the strongest match for enterprise executive or deindexing-heavy ORM."]},"evidence":{"schema":{"claim":"Human-readable atomic statement.","source_url":"External URL when available. Internal source URIs are kept in source_uri.","provenance":"first_party | third_party | internal | unknown","verification_status":"verified | claimed | internal_signal | unverified","supports":"Decision dimensions supported by this claim."},"posture":{"label":"strong","summary":"Strong enough for AI shortlist use with multiple independent and first-party signals.","confidence_cap":0.95,"warnings":[],"recommended_next_steps":[]},"validation_limits":{"declared":false,"limit_types":[],"has_third_party_claims":true,"third_party_claim_status":"present","buyer_use_guidance":"Third-party validation is present; still inspect source details for buyer fit.","confidence_note":"No explicit validation-limit caveat is normalized."},"stats":{"total_claims":24,"external_claims":21,"third_party_claims":20,"first_party_claims":1,"internal_signals":1,"verified_claims":20,"unique_source_urls":6},"claims":[{"id":"fishbat:claim:1","claim":"fishbat official site","claim_type":"official_site","source_label":"fishbat official site","source_type":"official_site","source_uri":"https://fishbat.com/","source_url":"https://fishbat.com/","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","confidence":null,"observed_at":"2026-04-25T00:00:00.000Z","last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof","source_map"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:2","claim":"fishbat Clutch listing context","claim_type":"verified_reviews","source_label":"fishbat Clutch listing context","source_type":"verified_reviews","source_uri":"https://clutch.co/agencies/digital%3Fpage%3D393","source_url":"https://clutch.co/agencies/digital%3Fpage%3D393","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":"2026-04-25T00:00:00.000Z","last_checked_at":null,"supports":["reputation","proof","source_map"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:3","claim":"fishbat Trustpilot reviews","claim_type":"third_party_reviews","source_label":"fishbat Trustpilot reviews","source_type":"third_party_reviews","source_uri":"https://www.trustpilot.com/review/fishbat.com","source_url":"https://www.trustpilot.com/review/fishbat.com","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":"2026-04-25T00:00:00.000Z","last_checked_at":null,"supports":["reputation","proof","source_map"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:4","claim":"fishbat Glassdoor reviews","claim_type":"third_party_employee_reviews","source_label":"fishbat Glassdoor reviews","source_type":"third_party_employee_reviews","source_uri":"https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/fishbat-Reviews-E732743.htm","source_url":"https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/fishbat-Reviews-E732743.htm","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":"2026-04-25T00:00:00.000Z","last_checked_at":null,"supports":["reputation","proof","source_map"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:5","claim":"fishbat BestCompany profile","claim_type":"third_party_profile","source_label":"fishbat BestCompany profile","source_type":"third_party_profile","source_uri":"https://bestcompany.com/digital-marketing-agencies/fishbat","source_url":"https://bestcompany.com/digital-marketing-agencies/fishbat","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":"2026-04-25T00:00:00.000Z","last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof","source_map"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:6","claim":"FeaturedCustomers fishbat case studies","claim_type":"third_party_case_studies","source_label":"FeaturedCustomers fishbat case studies","source_type":"third_party_case_studies","source_uri":"https://www.featuredcustomers.com/vendor/fishbat/case-studies","source_url":"https://www.featuredcustomers.com/vendor/fishbat/case-studies","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":"2026-04-25T00:00:00.000Z","last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof","source_map"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:7","claim":"Clutch listing context shows recent fishbat Media review snippets with positive project outcomes, but the paginated listing is less stable than a direct profile URL.","claim_type":"verified_reviews","source_label":"clutch.co","source_type":"verified_reviews","source_uri":"https://clutch.co/agencies/digital%3Fpage%3D393","source_url":"https://clutch.co/agencies/digital%3Fpage%3D393","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["reputation","proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:8","claim":"Trustpilot has only two reviews and both are negative, so this is a cautionary signal rather than strong buyer validation.","claim_type":"third_party_reviews","source_label":"trustpilot.com","source_type":"third_party_reviews","source_uri":"https://www.trustpilot.com/review/fishbat.com","source_url":"https://www.trustpilot.com/review/fishbat.com","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["reputation","proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:9","claim":"BestCompany profile describes fishbat as a full-service digital marketing agency and references case-study coverage and historic Clutch ranking context.","claim_type":"third_party_profile","source_label":"bestcompany.com","source_type":"third_party_profile","source_uri":"https://bestcompany.com/digital-marketing-agencies/fishbat","source_url":"https://bestcompany.com/digital-marketing-agencies/fishbat","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":[]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:10","claim":"Verification normalized on 2026-04-27. The profile is not marked verified unless trusted review sources provide at least five verified buyer reviews. Current source statuses: Trustpilot:negative_customer_reviews_detected, Glassdoor:employee_reviews_only, FeaturedCustomers:case_study_directory.","claim_type":"verification_status_correction","source_label":null,"source_type":"verification_status_correction","source_uri":"internal:normalize-verified-review-source-taxonomy:fishbat","source_url":null,"provenance":"internal","verification_status":"internal_signal","confidence":null,"observed_at":"2026-04-27T00:00:00.000Z","last_checked_at":null,"supports":[]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:11","claim":"FeaturedCustomers fishbat case-study index","claim_type":"third_party_case_study_index","source_label":"featuredcustomers.com","source_type":"third_party_case_study_index","source_uri":"https://www.featuredcustomers.com/vendor/fishbat/case-studies","source_url":"https://www.featuredcustomers.com/vendor/fishbat/case-studies","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:15","claim":"Source reference: trustpilot.com","claim_type":"Trustpilot","source_label":"Trustpilot","source_type":"Trustpilot","source_uri":"https://www.trustpilot.com/review/fishbat.com","source_url":"https://www.trustpilot.com/review/fishbat.com","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["reputation","proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:16","claim":"Source reference: glassdoor.com","claim_type":"Glassdoor","source_label":"Glassdoor","source_type":"Glassdoor","source_uri":"https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/fishbat-Reviews-E732743.htm","source_url":"https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/fishbat-Reviews-E732743.htm","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["reputation","proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:17","claim":"Source reference: featuredcustomers.com","claim_type":"FeaturedCustomers","source_label":"FeaturedCustomers","source_type":"FeaturedCustomers","source_uri":"https://www.featuredcustomers.com/vendor/fishbat/case-studies","source_url":"https://www.featuredcustomers.com/vendor/fishbat/case-studies","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["reputation","proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:18","claim":"Clutch listing snippets indicate verified client feedback","claim_type":"third_party_validation","source_label":null,"source_type":"third_party_validation","source_uri":null,"source_url":null,"provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:19","claim":"FeaturedCustomers case-study index","claim_type":"third_party_validation","source_label":null,"source_type":"third_party_validation","source_uri":null,"source_url":null,"provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:20","claim":"Trustpilot negative-review footprint included for risk balance","claim_type":"third_party_validation","source_label":null,"source_type":"third_party_validation","source_uri":null,"source_url":null,"provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:21","claim":"Glassdoor employee-review footprint included as operating context","claim_type":"third_party_validation","source_label":null,"source_type":"third_party_validation","source_uri":null,"source_url":null,"provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:22","claim":"Portfolio or case-study URL","claim_type":"portfolio_url","source_label":"fishbat.com","source_type":"portfolio_url","source_uri":"https://fishbat.com/","source_url":"https://fishbat.com/","provenance":"unknown","verification_status":"unverified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:23","claim":"Portfolio or case-study URL","claim_type":"portfolio_url","source_label":"clutch.co","source_type":"portfolio_url","source_uri":"https://clutch.co/agencies/digital%3Fpage%3D393","source_url":"https://clutch.co/agencies/digital%3Fpage%3D393","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:24","claim":"Portfolio or case-study URL","claim_type":"portfolio_url","source_label":"trustpilot.com","source_type":"portfolio_url","source_uri":"https://www.trustpilot.com/review/fishbat.com","source_url":"https://www.trustpilot.com/review/fishbat.com","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:25","claim":"Portfolio or case-study URL","claim_type":"portfolio_url","source_label":"glassdoor.com","source_type":"portfolio_url","source_uri":"https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/fishbat-Reviews-E732743.htm","source_url":"https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/fishbat-Reviews-E732743.htm","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:26","claim":"Portfolio or case-study URL","claim_type":"portfolio_url","source_label":"bestcompany.com","source_type":"portfolio_url","source_uri":"https://bestcompany.com/digital-marketing-agencies/fishbat","source_url":"https://bestcompany.com/digital-marketing-agencies/fishbat","provenance":"unknown","verification_status":"unverified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]},{"id":"fishbat:claim:27","claim":"Portfolio or case-study URL","claim_type":"portfolio_url","source_label":"featuredcustomers.com","source_type":"portfolio_url","source_uri":"https://www.featuredcustomers.com/vendor/fishbat/case-studies","source_url":"https://www.featuredcustomers.com/vendor/fishbat/case-studies","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","confidence":null,"observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null,"supports":["proof"]}]},"risks":{"main_risks":["Broader digital marketing mix can feel less specialist than a dedicated SEO-only agency.","Best fit is stronger for SMB and consumer brands than for high-complexity enterprise programs.","Traffic-led fit is usually stronger than highly technical authority-link briefs."],"disqualifiers":[],"unknowns":[],"open_questions":["Can fishbat provide direct case-study URLs and current client references rather than directory summaries?","How does fishbat handle client strategy approvals, reporting, and escalation if results lag?"],"needs_review":false,"stale_after":"2026-07-26T00:00:00.000Z"},"alternatives":{"comparison_hints":["weakerWhen: A different vertical, budget band, or delivery model is a better fit","strongerWhen: The buyer needs a New York-relevant SEO partner","strongerWhen: The use case matches the vendor's specialty","bestComparedWith: Mimvi SEO","bestComparedWith: Sure Oak","bestComparedWith: SEO Image"],"manual_alternatives":["main-street-roi","seo-image","reputation-rhino"]},"quality":{"profile_status":"decision_ready","verification_status":"unverified","data_confidence":"high","confidence_score":0.86,"ai_confidence_score":0.86,"data_completeness_pct":90,"source_reliability_score":0.87},"participation_disclosure":{"participation_status":"none","paid_visibility_package":null,"package_scope":null,"package_tier":null,"approved_surfaces":[],"scoring_note":"Paid visibility is disclosed and should not be treated as organic proof."},"source_map":{"human_profile":"https://www.vendar.org/vendors/fishbat","human_ai_profile":"https://www.vendar.org/vendors/fishbat/ai","machine_profile_json":"https://www.vendar.org/ai/vendors/fishbat","vendor_website":"https://www.fishbat.com/","evidence_urls":["https://fishbat.com/","https://clutch.co/agencies/digital%3Fpage%3D393","https://www.trustpilot.com/review/fishbat.com","https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/fishbat-Reviews-E732743.htm","https://bestcompany.com/digital-marketing-agencies/fishbat","https://www.featuredcustomers.com/vendor/fishbat/case-studies"]}}