{"schema_version":"vendar.ai.vendor-summary.v1","object_type":"vendor_decision_summary","canonical_url":"https://www.vendar.org/vendors/serafin-and-associates","machine_url":"https://www.vendar.org/ai/vendors/serafin-and-associates","last_updated_at":"2026-11-02T02:02:00.022Z","vendor":{"slug":"serafin-and-associates","name":"Serafin & Associates","website":"https://serafin.com/","one_line":"Chicago image-and-reputation firm for narrative control, issues response, executive trust, and public-facing brand repair.","company_type":"agency","headquarters_location":"Chicago, IL, USA","service_regions":["Chicago","Illinois","USA","Midwest"],"primary_services":["ORM","Review Management","Trustpilot Management","Google Reviews Management","Reddit Reputation Management"],"services_in_evidence":[]},"decision":{"verdict":{"label":"Not ranked yet","summary":"No published ranking admits this vendor on documented work yet; the profile shows what is on file.","note":"Moderate confidence; the profile is not verified by Vendar.","missing_for_recommended":[]},"score_out_of_100":null,"confidence":{"label":"Moderate confidence","score":0.78,"capped_reason":null,"source":"editor"},"best_for":["Executive reputation","Brand protection","Crisis repair"],"not_for":["Buyers that only need a lightweight, one-location review reply workflow with no broader ORM requirement.","Proposal-stage diligence is still needed for exact scope","legal posture"],"risks":["1 of 4 documented work claims come from independent sources; the rest are the agency's own account or sources it controls.","Complex legal or crisis-sensitive reputation matters still need proposal-stage confirmation on execution model."],"open_questions":["Ask for the hourly rate, setup fee: not published.","Ask for two client references you can call: only 1 independent account of its work on file.","Ask which case is closest to your business and what the measured result was: no proof on file carries a number.","Is a new buyer contracting with Serafin, Mercury Illinois, or another Mercury/Omnicom entity?","Can the firm provide confidential public-affairs or crisis references for a comparable issue profile?"],"not_published":["project minimum","hourly rate","setup fee"],"score_basis":"Not ranked on any published question yet","profile_scores":{"version":"2026.11-profile-scores","completeness":{"data_completeness_pct":52,"label":"Data completeness, separate from the ranking score","parts":[{"key":"identity","label":"Who the company is: website, headquarters, founding year, team size, logo, regions served","points":20,"max":20,"detail":"complete"},{"key":"fit","label":"Fit: services, industries, client types","points":15,"max":15,"detail":"complete"},{"key":"commercial","label":"Commercial terms: model, entry price, hourly rate, minimum term, setup fee","points":13,"max":20,"detail":"hourly rate, setup fee"},{"key":"work","label":"Documented work: cases naming a client and a result (target 5) and work claims overall (target 10)","points":4,"max":30,"detail":"0 cases with a named client and a result, 4 work claims"},{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation: rating and review count on two or more platforms, each with 10 or more reviews","points":0,"max":15,"detail":"0 platforms with a rating and 10 or more reviews"}]},"trust":{"trust_score_out_of_100":49,"label":"Trust score, separate from the ranking score","parts":[{"key":"independence","label":"Who is speaking: independent sources among work claims (full marks at 40%)","points":19,"max":30,"detail":"1 of 4 work claims are independent"},{"key":"checked","label":"Checked against the source page: confirmed, or half for partly confirmed","points":0,"max":25,"detail":"0 confirmed, 0 partly, of 7 with a source"},{"key":"quoted_numbers","label":"Numbers backed by a verbatim quote from the source","points":20,"max":20,"detail":"0 of 0"},{"key":"fresh","label":"Seen within the last 365 days","points":0,"max":15,"detail":"0 of 12"},{"key":"not_contradicted","label":"Not contradicted: claims their source no longer supports","points":10,"max":10,"detail":"0 not supported by their page"}]}},"fit_source":{"bestFor":"editorial","notFor":"editorial"}},"pricing":{"display":"From $7,500 per month, retainer","model":"retainer","minimum_monthly_budget_usd":7500,"minimum_project_size_usd":null,"pricing_range_min_usd":7500,"pricing_range_max_usd":15000,"hourly_rate_range":null,"public_summary":null,"secondary_options":[],"pricing_known":true,"display_basis":"published by the agency","setup_fee_usd":null,"contract_min_months":3,"engagement_models":["retainer","project"],"band_note":null,"status":"disclosed","not_disclosed":["project minimum","hourly rate","setup fee"],"agency_stated_fields":[]},"evidence":{"posture":{"label":"adequate","summary":"Usable as shortlist context: 1 of 4 documented work claims come from independent sources; check the sources before outreach."},"independent_validation_scope":"independent_context","independent_validation_label":"Independent context found","independence_statement":"1 of 4 documented work claims come from independent sources; the rest are the agency's own account or sources it controls.","source_counts":{"definition":"Each claim on file counted once by who wrote it. Only 'independent' counts as outside proof.","total":12,"by_speaker":{"independent":6,"affiliated":0,"vendor_controlled":0,"vendor":6},"work_claims":4,"independent_work_claims":1,"independent_work_share":0.25,"unique_urls":4,"scope":"whole_ledger","scope_note":"Counted over every claim in the ledger (claims_on_file), not over the claims array, which lists at most 20."},"claims":[{"id":"serafin-and-associates:claim:22","claim":"Portfolio or case-study URL","claim_type":"portfolio_url","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"independent","counts_as_independent_work":true,"needs":[],"client_name":null,"result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":null,"source_label":"glassdoor.com","source_url":"https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Serafin-Reviews-E7367556.htm","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","check_status":"unchecked","observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null},{"id":"serafin-and-associates:claim:18","claim":"Portfolio or case-study URL","claim_type":"portfolio_url","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":null,"result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":null,"source_label":"serafin.com","source_url":"https://serafin.com/","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"unchecked","observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null},{"id":"serafin-and-associates:claim:19","claim":"Portfolio or case-study URL","claim_type":"portfolio_url","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":null,"result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":null,"source_label":"serafin.com","source_url":"https://serafin.com/team/","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"unchecked","observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null},{"id":"serafin-and-associates:claim:20","claim":"Portfolio or case-study URL","claim_type":"portfolio_url","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":null,"result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":null,"source_label":"serafin.com","source_url":"https://serafin.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/MERCURY-PUBLIC-AFFAIRS-ANNOUNCES-MERGER-WITH-SERAFIN-ASSOCIATES-11.21.24.pdf","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"unchecked","observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null},{"id":"serafin-and-associates:claim:13","claim":"A review platform company profile without verified reviews","claim_type":"third_party_validation","describes_work":false,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"independent","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":null,"result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":null,"source_label":null,"source_url":null,"provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"unchecked","observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null},{"id":"serafin-and-associates:claim:14","claim":"Glassdoor employee-review footprint used only as operating context","claim_type":"third_party_validation","describes_work":false,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"independent","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":null,"result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":null,"source_label":null,"source_url":null,"provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"unchecked","observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null},{"id":"serafin-and-associates:claim:15","claim":"Mercury merger announcement adds business-entity and capability validation","claim_type":"third_party_validation","describes_work":false,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"independent","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":null,"result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":null,"source_label":null,"source_url":null,"provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"unchecked","observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null},{"id":"serafin-and-associates:claim:16","claim":"A review platform profile without reviews","claim_type":"third_party_validation","describes_work":false,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"independent","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":null,"result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":null,"source_label":null,"source_url":null,"provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"unchecked","observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null},{"id":"serafin-and-associates:claim:17","claim":"Employee review excluded","claim_type":"third_party_validation","describes_work":false,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"independent","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":null,"result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":null,"source_label":null,"source_url":null,"provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"unchecked","observed_at":null,"last_checked_at":null}],"validation_limit":"Usable as shortlist context with a caveat: 1 of 4 documented work claims come from independent sources; the rest are the agency's own account or sources it controls.","independent_work_validation":{"independent_work_claims":1,"work_claims":4,"share":0.25,"gate_share":0.333,"meets_gate":false},"has_any_independent_validation":true,"claims_on_file":12,"claims_listed":9,"claims_truncated":true,"listed_counts":{"in_ledger":9,"work_claims":4,"independent":6,"independent_work_claims":1}},"alternatives":{"comparison_hints":["Compare against adjacent Chicago ORM vendors for budget fit, crisis depth, and review-management strength."],"vendor_slugs":[]},"citation":{"recommendation_readiness":"cite_with_source_context","preferred_sources":[{"source_url":"https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Serafin-Reviews-E7367556.htm","source_label":"glassdoor.com","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","supports":["source_map"],"cited_claims":["Serafin Glassdoor reviews"]},{"source_url":"https://serafin.com/","source_label":"serafin.com","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["source_map"],"cited_claims":["Serafin official site"]},{"source_url":"https://serafin.com/team/","source_label":"serafin.com","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["proof","source_map"],"cited_claims":["Serafin team and client context","Team page emphasizes senior communications, campaign, newsroom, public affairs, reputation, media, advocacy, and earned-media experience, with a public client-logo section.","Serafin team and services context"]},{"source_url":"https://serafin.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/MERCURY-PUBLIC-AFFAIRS-ANNOUNCES-MERGER-WITH-SERAFIN-ASSOCIATES-11.21.24.pdf","source_label":"serafin.com","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["source_map"],"cited_claims":["Mercury and Serafin merger announcement","Mercury announcement says Serafin merged into Mercury's Illinois business, expanding public affairs and strategic communications capabilities in the Midwest and nationally."]}],"required_caveats":["1 of 4 documented work claims come from independent sources; the rest are the agency's own account or sources it controls.","Complex legal or crisis-sensitive reputation matters still need proposal-stage confirmation on execution model."],"do_not_infer":["Do not infer headquarters from service-area coverage.","Do not treat paid visibility as organic ranking proof.","Do not present a source-thin profile as independently verified."]},"quality":{"profile_status":"reviewed","verification_status":"unverified","needs_review":false,"data_completeness_pct":52,"stale_after":"2026-07-26T00:00:00.000Z","sources_checked_at":"2026-04-27T00:00:00.000Z","profile_status_note":"collected and reviewed by an editor","consistency":{"version":"2026.11-profile-consistency","ok":true,"issues":[]},"standard":{"version":"2026.10-profile-standard","open_items":[{"check":"Decision layer complete: score, verdict, reason, best position","detail":"not ranked","closed_by":"system"},{"check":"Three strongest proofs name a client and a measured, dated result","detail":"0 of 3","closed_by":"collector"},{"check":"Every claim has an observation date","detail":"0 of 12","closed_by":"collector"},{"check":"At least a third of documented work comes from independent sources","detail":"1 of 4 work claims","closed_by":"collector"},{"check":"At least three named clients","detail":"2 named","closed_by":"collector"},{"check":"JSON-LD carries Vendar's rating as a Review and an absolute logo","detail":"built from the same view; checked on the live page by QA","closed_by":"system"},{"check":"Every machine claim has an id, a provenance and an observation date","detail":"0 of 9 dated","closed_by":"collector"},{"check":"Re-check date ahead and data younger than 180 days","detail":"data 3 days old","closed_by":"collector"}]}},"participation_disclosure":{"paid_visibility":false,"status":"none","package":null,"scoring_note":"Paid visibility is disclosed and never treated as quality evidence."},"source_map":{"human_profile":"https://www.vendar.org/vendors/serafin-and-associates","machine_profile_json":"https://www.vendar.org/ai/vendors/serafin-and-associates","vendor_website":"https://serafin.com/","evidence_urls":["https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Serafin-Reviews-E7367556.htm","https://serafin.com/","https://serafin.com/team/","https://serafin.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/MERCURY-PUBLIC-AFFAIRS-ANNOUNCES-MERGER-WITH-SERAFIN-ASSOCIATES-11.21.24.pdf"]},"model_version":"Evidence-weighted ranking 2026.11.7","generated_at":"2026-11-05T05:00:28.129Z","verification":{"status":"unverified","sources_checked_at":"2026-04-27T00:00:00.000Z","stale_after":"2026-07-26T00:00:00.000Z"},"company":{"founded":{"value":1987,"status":"disclosed","source":"profile","sources":[],"conflict":false},"team_size":{"value":"10-49","status":"disclosed","source":"profile","stated_by_source":null},"headquarters":{"value":"Chicago, IL, USA","status":"disclosed","source":"profile"},"service_regions":["Chicago","Illinois","USA","Midwest"],"services":[{"category":"Marketing","subcategories":["ORM","Review Management","Trustpilot Management","Google Reviews Management","Reddit Reputation Management","Glassdoor Reputation","Yelp Reputation","Negative Search Cleanup","Negative Content Removal","Review Removal Services","Deindexing Services","Reputation Suppression","ORM for SaaS","ORM for Ecommerce","ORM for Local Business","ORM for Founders","Reputation for Startups","ORM Under $5k/mo","Crisis Repair","Social Monitoring","SERM","Brand Protection","Negative Suppression","Executive Reputation","Review Repair","Crisis Response","Local Reputation","Content Removal (Legal / DMCA)","Negative SEO / Attack Handling","SERP Control","Entity Management","Review Generation"]}],"industries":["B2B","Corporate","Executive","Public Affairs","Professional Services"],"client_types":["enterprise","executive","mid_market","professional_services"],"languages":[],"technologies":[],"certifications":[],"awards":[],"named_clients":["Mercury Public Affairs","Mercury Illinois"],"reputation_sources":[],"process":{"workflow":["Reputation audit and baseline capture","Risk prioritization across reviews, search, and brand mentions","Execution across cleanup, monitoring, and positive-signal support","Monthly review and iteration"],"onboarding":["Issue intake and search-risk review","Baseline review and SERP audit","Priority scenario mapping","First ORM sprint"],"reporting":"monthly"},"provenance_note":"Company fields come from the vendor profile; only fields with status verified were checked by Vendar."},"agency_stated":null,"best_position":null,"positions":[],"client_voice":{"observed_at":"2026-11-02T15:31:47.986Z","sample_share_read":null,"review_drive_caution":null,"platforms":[{"platform":"Google","url":"https://www.google.com/maps?cid=6638359607319845924","rating":null,"reviews":null,"bbb_grade":null,"complaints_last_3_years":null}],"average_rating":null,"total_reviews":0,"reviews_read":0,"last_12_months_share":null,"negative_share":null,"owner_answer_rate":null,"review_burst":null,"summary":null,"praised":[],"criticized":[],"results_reported_by_clients":[],"hired_for":[],"client_types":[],"named_testimonials":[],"note":"Ratings and reviews from independent platforms; quotes are verbatim and checked against the review text. Testimonials published by the agency are labelled as such."}}