Vendar
AI vendor intelligence
Find Match

Vendar

AI vendor intelligence for teams that want structured signals, cleaner comparisons, and better buying decisions.

Decision scoringEvidence-led profilesBuyer-first UX
Explore
Marketing pagesShortlistFind MatchMapParticipateHow scoring works
Platform

Browse vendors, compare top options side by side, and access the internal admin workspace when needed.

Browse vendorsAdmin

© 2026 Vendar.org. Structured vendor intelligence for modern buyers.

MarketingSERMNew YorkLocal Reputation

Best Local Reputation Management Agencies in New York

12 vendorsNew York, USALocal Reputation
No paid placements12 agencies scored105 case studies combined6 verified profilesUpdated September 2026
All SERMBrand ProtectionSuppressionExecutiveReview RepairCrisisLocal ReputationContent Removal
+4 more scenarios on the New York SERM page
Filter by monthly budget
All budgets< $2K/mo$2–5K/mo$5–15K/mo$15K+/mo

Local Reputation shortlist — New York

Main Street ROI logo
1
Top 1Official Sources

Main Street ROI

New York, NY, USAagencyTeam 10-49

Small-business SEO and digital marketing agency built for practical ROI, lead generation, and local growth.

Local Reputation
Direct fit for local reputation, supporting profile language around review management.
Small BusinessBy BudgetSERMB2B Demand GenCAC Optimizationlocal reputationProfessional ServicesNew York10 case studies9 named clients
Verified Apr 2026
77/100
GoodTop 30%
Cases
10
Proof
Strong proof
From $3K/mo
View profileCompare
Reputation Rhino logo
2
Top 2VerifiedOfficial Sources

Reputation Rhino

New York, NY, USAagencyTeam 10-49

New York ORM agency for search cleanup, review management, and brand protection.

Local Reputation
Direct fit for local reputation and review management, industry proof leans into Local Business.
Review managementGoogle review cleanupSERMBrand ProtectionContent Removal (Legal / DMCA)local reputationreview managementLocal Business2 case studies
Verified Apr 2026
93/100
ExcellentTop 5%
Cases
2
Proof
Strong proof
From $4K/mo
View profileCompare
SEO Image logo
3
Top 3Official Sources

SEO Image

New York, NY, USAagencyTeam 10-49

NYC SEO and reputation-focused agency for brands that need search visibility and trust signals together.

Local Reputation
Direct fit for local reputation, supporting profile language around review management.
Local SEOHigh-TicketSERMAI Search VisibilityAnswer Engine Optimizationlocal reputationProfessional ServicesNew York4 case studies2 named clients
Verified Apr 2026
86/100
ExcellentTop 15%
Cases
4
Proof
Strong proof
From $3K/mo
View profileCompare
Side-by-side comparison
Top 3 compared side-by-sideScore · Pricing · Proof
Main Street ROI
77/100
#1
Best score
Reputation Rhino
93/100
#2
SEO Image
86/100
#3
Pricing$3K/mo↑$4K/mo$3K/mo
Case studies10↑24
LA coverageVerifyVerifyVerify
Team size10-4910-4910-49
Scroll to see more agencies
fishbat logo
4

fishbat

New York, NY, USAagencyTeam 10-49

New York digital marketing agency with SEO support for SMB, local, and consumer brands.

Local Reputation
Direct fit for local reputation and review management, industry proof leans into Professional Services.
Small BusinessLocal SEOSERMAuthority LinksBrand Mentionslocal reputationreview managementProfessional Services11 case studies4 named clients
Verified Apr 2026
86/100
ExcellentTop 15%
Cases
11
Proof
Strong proof
From $3K/mo
View profileCompare
OpenMoves logo
5
Verified

OpenMoves

Huntington, NY, USAagencyTeam 10-49

New York performance marketing agency with SEO, CRO, and analytics support for in-house and ecommerce teams.

Local Reputation
Direct fit for local reputation and review management, industry proof leans into Professional Services.
EcommerceConversion GrowthSERMAgencies with Proven ResultsAttribution / Analyticslocal reputationreview managementProfessional Services20 case studies9 named clients
Verified Jun 2026
94/100
ExcellentTop 5%
Cases
20
Proof
Strong proof
From $4K/mo
View profileCompare

Not sure which agency fits your budget?

Answer 3 questions — get a shortlist matched to your team size, goals, and spend.

Get matched
Austin Williams logo
6
Official Sources

Austin Williams

New York, NY, USAagencyTeam 10-49

Long Island and New York agency for reputation management, brand strategy, healthcare, higher education, financial, and professional-services growth.

Local Reputation
Direct fit for local reputation and review management, industry proof leans into Healthcare.
Review managementSocial monitoringSERMBrand ProtectionContent Removal (Legal / DMCA)local reputationreview managementHealthcare9 case studies9 named clients
Verified Jul 2026
86/100
ExcellentTop 15%
Cases
9
Proof
Strong proof
From $4K/mo
View profileCompare
Marketing Maven logo
7
Verified

Marketing Maven

New York, NY, USAagencyTeam 10-49

New York integrated marketing agency with SEO support for brand-led, founder-led, and consumer growth programs.

Local Reputation
Direct fit for local reputation, supporting profile language around review management.
FoundersContent-ledSERMBrand MentionsBrand Protectionlocal reputationProfessional ServicesNew York10 case studies7 named clients
Verified Apr 2026
77/100
GoodTop 30%
Cases
10
Proof
Strong proof
From $3K/mo
View profileCompare
Reputation Pros logo
8
Official Sources

Reputation Pros

New York, NY, USAagencyTeam 10-49

NYC ORM specialist for suppression, content removal support, review cleanup, and search-result repair.

Local Reputation
supporting profile language around local reputation and review management, industry proof leans into Professional Services.
Negative content removalReputation suppressionSERMBrand ProtectionContent Removal (Legal / DMCA)Professional ServicesNew York1 case study
Verified Apr 2026
93/100
ExcellentTop 5%
Cases
1
Proof
Moderate proof
From $5K/mo
View profileCompare
5WPR logo
9
VerifiedOfficial Sources

5WPR

New York, NY, USAagencyTeam 50-199

NYC PR firm with reputation management, brand protection, and startup-facing communications support.

Local Reputation
supporting profile language around local reputation and review management, industry proof leans into Consumer.
Brand protectionReputation for startupsSERMBrand ProtectionContent Removal (Legal / DMCA)ConsumerNew York6 case studies3 named clients
Verified Apr 2026
94/100
ExcellentTop 5%
Cases
6
Proof
Strong proof
From $7K/mo
View profileCompare
Amsive logo
10
Official Sources

Amsive

New York, NY, USAagencyTeam 10-49

Data-led performance marketing agency with enterprise SEO capabilities for larger growth organizations.

Local Reputation
supporting profile language around local reputation and review management, industry proof leans into Healthcare.
EnterpriseTechnical SEOSERMAgencies with Proven ResultsAttribution / AnalyticsHealthcareNew York8 case studies6 named clients
Verified Apr 2026
95/100
ExcellentTop 5%
Cases
8
Proof
Strong proof
From $8K/mo
View profileCompare
12Next
How we rank these agencies
Proof depth
Case studies, named clients, and verifiable source citations from official channels.
Pricing visibility
Disclosed retainer floors, project minimums, or hourly ranges - not "contact us".
Local market coverage
Service regions, city-specific landing pages, and geography-relevant case evidence.
Specialist depth
Service match for this specific intent, not just broad category presence.
Confidence score
Data completeness and profile freshness - incomplete profiles rank lower.

Scores are calculated automatically from structured data. No paid placement affects ranking position.

Service Hub

This shortlist continues the Brand Protection hub

Use the hub to understand scope and buyer fit, then use this New York page to compare actual agencies, proof signals, and shortlist ranking for local reputation.

Open Brand Protection Hub
What to verify before hiring for local reputation
Proof that the agency has handled local reputation work before.
A clear scope, timeline, and implementation model.
Visible case studies, sources, or client evidence.
Pricing or budget-fit signals before outreach.
A practical next-step recommendation, not a vague strategy deck.
How to read a New York local reputation proposal

Ask for relevant proof

Make sure the agency can show work connected to local reputation, not only broad local reputation management claims.

Clarify the operating model

Confirm who owns strategy, implementation, reporting, and technical coordination before you commit.

Validate the commercial fit

Use budget, project floor, and team-size signals to avoid shortlisting agencies that are structurally mismatched.

Compare Local Reputation in Other Cities

Local Reputation in Los Angeles

Los Angeles, USA shortlist with the same buyer context.

Local Reputation in Chicago

Chicago, USA shortlist with the same buyer context.

Local Reputation in Miami

Miami, USA shortlist with the same buyer context.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes this Local Reputation shortlist different from the broader New York SERM page?

This page keeps the same market context but re-ranks vendors for local reputation fit, using the intent definition, service signals, proof quality, and buyer context.

Should I start with the Local Reputation page or the broader SERM page?

Start here if you already know the problem is local reputation. Use the broader SERM page when you are still deciding between multiple SEO workstreams.

Why does Vendar link this page back to the service hub?

The hub explains the service category, while this page compares vendors in New York. Together they form the path from service understanding to shortlist selection.

Need a more exact match?

Add budget, timing, and business context on top of this shortlist to get a personalised recommendation.

Get a personalised match